How neoliberal economics reshaped Australian higher education, why the humanities matter, and the unfinished pursuit of wisdom

By Andrew Klein
Introduction: What are universities actually producing?
There is a question we should be asking about Australian higher education.
Have we gradually changed the purpose of the university from developing educated, questioning and socially responsible human beings to producing economically useful graduates?
It is not an unreasonable question. Over several decades, Australian universities have undergone substantial changes in their funding arrangements, governance, institutional priorities and relationship with the commercial sector. Competition, financial performance, employment outcomes and measurable productivity have become increasingly influential in determining how universities operate.
These changes have not been entirely without merit. Higher education needed to expand access, respond to changing workforce requirements, improve accountability and maintain financial sustainability. Universities must prepare people for employment, and technical education is essential to Australia’s economic and scientific future.
But there is a distinction between preparing people to participate in an economy and preparing them to understand the society in which that economy operates.
That distinction is becoming increasingly important.
We are educating people to design sophisticated technologies, manage complex organisations, analyse enormous quantities of information and develop systems that influence almost every aspect of human life. Yet we must ask whether we are giving equal attention to their capacity to examine the assumptions, values and consequences behind those systems.
The humanities and social sciences are particularly important here. History, sociology, philosophy, anthropology, political science, literature and the creative arts provide ways of examining the human experience that cannot be adequately replaced by technical instruction or financial analysis.
Their contribution may not always produce an immediate commercial return. But their absence can carry a considerable social cost.
To understand why, we need to examine two interconnected systems: the human capacity for reasoning and the institutional structures through which society develops and applies knowledge.
The first is our human operating system. The second is the university.
And the question connecting them is this:
Are we developing the capacity to understand and question the systems we are becoming increasingly capable of operating?
I. The human operating system: intelligence is not wisdom
Human beings are biological systems. Our capacity to reason developed through evolution, experience, social interaction and the practical demands of survival.
Long before philosophy or formal education, people needed to recognise patterns, remember experiences, distinguish danger from safety, cooperate with others and make decisions under uncertainty.
These abilities were essential.
But the human brain did not evolve to guarantee objective reasoning. It developed cognitive mechanisms that were useful in particular environments.
We recognise patterns. We make assumptions. We respond emotionally to threats. We use mental shortcuts to reach decisions without examining every available possibility.
These mechanisms are not inherently defective. They are often useful.
The difficulty arises when a shortcut that works in one environment becomes unreliable in another.
A brain adapted to immediate social and physical circumstances must now interpret international conflicts, financial markets, political arguments, epidemiological statistics, artificial intelligence and complex administrative systems.
The demands have changed enormously.
Our cognitive architecture has not necessarily changed at the same pace.
The ancient recognition of human fallibility
The philosophical traditions of Greece, India and China recognised that human beings do not automatically know what they think they know.
Socrates questioned the assumptions behind apparently confident beliefs. His method exposed the difference between being able to articulate an opinion and being able to justify it.
Aristotle examined logic, knowledge and practical judgement. His concept of phronesis, or practical wisdom, concerned the ability to judge what was appropriate in particular circumstances.
Classical Indian philosophy developed sophisticated traditions of logic and epistemology, including the Nyaya examination of valid knowledge, inference and argument.
Chinese philosophy explored the relationship between language, reasoning and responsibility. The Confucian principle of Zhengming, the rectification of names, asked whether the descriptions people used corresponded with the responsibilities and realities they represented.
These traditions differed considerably, but they shared an important concern: the relationship between belief, evidence, judgement and conduct.
The European Enlightenment subsequently renewed the examination of authority, evidence and reason. Francis Bacon investigated the intellectual assumptions that distort understanding. René Descartes developed methodological doubt. David Hume examined the limits of knowledge and inference. Immanuel Kant explored the conditions of human understanding.
The scientific method developed as one of humanity’s most important responses to the limitations of individual judgement.
Observation, hypothesis, experimentation, replication, peer criticism and revision established procedures through which conclusions could be examined by others.
The important development was not simply that people began using reason.
It was that they developed methods through which reasoning itself could be challenged.
Individual intelligence can produce an explanation. Collective scrutiny can reveal its weaknesses.
The discovery of cognitive bias
Twentieth-century psychology added another dimension to this discussion.
Researchers including Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky demonstrated that human beings regularly employ cognitive shortcuts when making decisions under uncertainty.
These shortcuts can produce predictable errors.
We may favour information that confirms existing beliefs. We may overestimate the likelihood of events that are easily recalled. We may become anchored to an initial proposition. We may place greater confidence in our judgement than the available evidence warrants.
These tendencies are not confined to people with limited education.
Intelligent, highly educated individuals are also susceptible.
Indeed, intellectual ability can sometimes make a person more effective at defending an existing belief rather than examining it.
Human intelligence does not necessarily serve the pursuit of truth. Sometimes it serves the protection of belief.
This is an uncomfortable observation, but an important one.
The emotional dimension
Emotion is sometimes treated as the enemy of rational thought. That is an oversimplification.
Emotions help us recognise significance, evaluate risk, establish relationships and respond to circumstances.
Fear can identify danger. Anger can signal perceived injustice. Compassion can direct attention towards suffering.
The problem arises when emotional intensity substitutes for examination.
Fear can make an unsupported threat appear convincing. Anger can make an accusation seem established. Greed can make an immediate opportunity appear more attractive than its long-term consequences justify.
Human reasoning is also influenced by identity, loyalty, social belonging and the desire to defend previous decisions.
A person may resist evidence not because it is particularly weak, but because accepting it would require reconsidering a deeply held belief or acknowledging that an earlier decision was mistaken.
We therefore need to distinguish between the capacity to reason and the willingness to examine our reasoning.
This brings us to a proposition that has particular relevance to education:
Intelligence helps us operate the system. Critical thinking helps us examine it. Wisdom helps us recognise when the system itself needs changing.
These are related but distinct capacities.
Intelligence helps us understand and manipulate information. Critical thinking allows us to examine claims, assumptions and evidence. Wisdom requires judgement about consequences, responsibilities and what ought to be done.
Knowledge does not automatically produce wisdom.
Experience does not automatically produce wisdom.
Nor does intelligence guarantee sound judgement.
Wisdom requires reflection, intellectual humility and a willingness to reconsider what we believe when the evidence or circumstances demand it.
And this is where the university enters the discussion.
II. The transformation of Australian higher education
To understand the present structure of Australian universities, we need to go back to the late 1980s.
The reforms introduced by Labor Education Minister John Dawkins in 1987 were a major turning point.
The Unified National System brought universities and former colleges of advanced education into a more integrated national higher education system. Participation expanded, institutions grew and competition for students and resources became increasingly important.
The introduction of the Higher Education Contribution Scheme, or HECS, in 1989 also changed the relationship between students and the financing of university education.
These reforms had important benefits. They helped transform Australian higher education from a relatively small, elite system into a much larger system with broader opportunities for participation.
But they also introduced a more market-oriented institutional environment.
Universities increasingly competed for students, research funding and institutional resources. Government funding became more closely associated with specified outputs, performance and institutional priorities.
The university was no longer simply an educational institution receiving public support to pursue teaching and research.
It increasingly became an organisation required to demonstrate measurable performance and financial sustainability.
The influence of neoliberalism and New Public Management
Neoliberal economic ideology places considerable emphasis on market competition, individual choice, private enterprise, efficiency and the application of market mechanisms to areas traditionally organised through public institutions.
New Public Management brought related ideas into public administration, emphasising performance targets, financial accountability, managerial control and measurable outputs.
These approaches increasingly influenced university governance.
Universities adopted corporate-style executive structures, strategic performance plans, quantified research targets, competitive internal funding arrangements, commercial partnerships, recruitment targets and institutional rankings.
There is nothing inherently wrong with measuring performance.
Universities should be accountable for public money, educational standards and research quality.
The difficulty arises when what can be measured becomes more important than what is valuable.
Research output can be counted. Citations can be counted. Student enrolments can be counted. Graduation rates, research income and commercial partnerships can be counted.
But how do we measure whether a university has helped someone become a more thoughtful citizen?
How do we measure whether a philosophy graduate has developed a greater capacity to recognise defective reasoning?
How do we measure the contribution of sociology to understanding institutional exclusion?
How do we measure the long-term benefit of historical research that changes how a community understands its past?
Some of these contributions can be evaluated, but they resist simple financial measurement.
The problem is not accountability itself.
It is the choice of what counts as accountability.
When the institution measures what it can easily count, it risks neglecting what it cannot easily quantify.
III. When the market begins to determine the value of knowledge
Perhaps the clearest example of the changing priorities of Australian higher education was the Morrison government’s Job-ready Graduates package, introduced in 2020 and implemented from January 2021.
The policy deliberately changed student contribution amounts across different disciplines, seeking to influence student choices towards areas considered important for national workforce requirements.
The financial changes were substantial.
| Discipline group | 2020 annual student contribution | 2021 annual student contribution | Change |
| Humanities, society and culture, communications | $6,804 | $14,500 | +113% |
| Law and commerce | $11,355 | $14,500 | +28% |
| Science, engineering and IT | $9,698 | $7,950 | -18% |
| Teaching, nursing and selected other disciplines | $6,804 | $3,950 | -42% |
These are the original annual contribution amounts before subsequent indexation.
The policy was not simply allocating funding differently between universities. It was deliberately using financial incentives to influence student choices.
In economic terms, it was a form of price signalling.
The underlying message was that some areas of study were more valuable to the national economy than others.
A student interested in philosophy, history, sociology or communications was confronted with a substantially higher financial contribution than a student entering several government-prioritised disciplines.
But the subsequent Australian Universities Accord Final Report found that the policy had largely failed to influence student demand in the way intended. It also identified significant financial disadvantages for students in humanities, society and culture, human movement and communications.
This raises an obvious question:
What was achieved by making the study of human society, history, philosophy and culture more expensive when the intended behavioural change largely failed to materialise?
And perhaps an even more important question:
Who decided that the economic return associated with a particular qualification was an adequate measure of its value to society?
What happened to enrolments?
We should be careful not to claim that every humanities discipline is disappearing.
Australian Government figures for domestic commencing students between 2016 and 2025 show different trajectories across broad fields.
Information technology and engineering experienced substantial growth. Health and education also increased.
Society and culture declined modestly, while creative arts experienced a more substantial decline.
| Field of education | 2016 commencements | 2025 commencements | Change |
| Information technology | 12,341 | 19,072 | +54.5% |
| Engineering and related technologies | 19,762 | 25,095 | +27.0% |
| Health | 79,928 | 95,675 | +19.7% |
| Education | 42,588 | 46,794 | +9.9% |
| Society and culture | 102,091 | 98,177 | -3.8% |
| Creative arts | 31,439 | 22,801 | -27.5% |
These figures do not establish that government funding policy caused the changes. Labour market conditions, student preferences, population changes, course availability and financial circumstances also influence enrolments.
Nor should the broad category of society and culture be treated as a direct measure of humanities enrolments alone.
Nevertheless, the figures demonstrate that different disciplines have experienced substantially different trajectories.
The more defensible argument is not that the humanities have disappeared.
It is that their position within the funding and institutional environment has changed.
A discipline does not need to disappear to become institutionally disadvantaged.
IV. The commercial university and the problem of institutional incentives
Another important part of the transformation has been the expansion of the international education market.
International education is a major Australian export industry. It provides employment, supports university operations, contributes to research funding and brings considerable economic activity to Australian cities.
International students make an enormous contribution to Australian universities and society.
The concern is not their presence.
It is the degree to which university finances have become exposed to international student revenue.
The Victorian Auditor-General’s 2025 audit of TAFEs and universities found that international student teaching revenue had driven the financial recovery of much of the Victorian university sector between 2023 and 2025.
Across the sector, international student teaching revenue increased by $1.82 billion over that period. In 2025, revenue from teaching international students exceeded revenue from teaching domestic students for the sector as a whole.
This is a significant structural development.
Universities must attract students, maintain revenue, compete internationally and invest in facilities, marketing and administration.
These pressures can influence decisions about course offerings, staffing, research priorities and institutional strategy.
They do not automatically produce poor educational outcomes. But they create incentives that deserve examination.
The university must remain financially sustainable, but financial sustainability should be a means of supporting its educational and research responsibilities, not the ultimate definition of its purpose.
The audit culture
The transformation has also affected internal university governance.
Corporate-style executive structures, performance reviews, research targets and financial reporting have become increasingly influential.
A 2024 historical analysis by Lee Parker, James Guthrie and Ann Martin-Sardesai examined the development of financial performance measurement, audit practices, competitive student recruitment and commercial research expectations in Australian universities.
Their analysis identifies the growth of an audit culture and raises questions about the consequences for institutional identity, academic autonomy and the university’s contribution to civil society.
The concern is not that universities should be free from scrutiny.
Academic work must be accountable to evidence, methodological standards and intellectual criticism.
The concern is that the mechanisms used to measure institutional performance can increasingly influence what universities consider worthwhile.
When research priorities are strongly influenced by commercial funding, when academic careers depend upon quantified performance targets, and when courses are treated primarily as financial assets, the institution risks narrowing its conception of intellectual value.
A university that is reluctant to investigate questions because they may be commercially inconvenient is not fulfilling its full public responsibility.
V. The neglected relationship between technical knowledge and human understanding
This is where the argument moves beyond funding arrangements and institutional management.
There is a distinction between education that prepares people for employment and education that prepares them to understand the world in which they will work and live.
We need both.
A medical graduate requires technical knowledge, but medicine also involves ethics, communication, cultural understanding and the ability to recognise the social circumstances affecting a patient’s health.
An engineer requires mathematical and technical competence, but engineering projects involve environmental consequences, public safety and decisions about the allocation of resources.
An economist requires economic knowledge, but economics cannot be adequately understood without considering human behaviour, institutions, political power and the social consequences of economic decisions.
An AI developer requires technical expertise, but the development and deployment of artificial intelligence involve privacy, discrimination, autonomy, accountability and human rights.
These are not optional additions to professional competence.
They are part of understanding what professional competence actually means.
Consider an AI system used to assess eligibility for public assistance.
Its designers may understand machine learning, statistical modelling and data architecture.
But do they understand poverty?
Do they understand disability?
Do they understand trauma?
Do they understand the effects of administrative exclusion?
Do they understand the social consequences of treating people as statistical categories?
Technical competence cannot automatically supply that understanding.
The humanities and social sciences help us examine the world in which technical knowledge is applied.
History helps us understand how institutions develop and how decisions produce consequences over generations.
Sociology examines relationships, inequality, social structures and institutional power.
Philosophy examines knowledge, ethics, reasoning and the foundations of belief.
Political science examines authority, governance and the distribution of power.
Anthropology examines human societies, cultural differences and the ways people understand their worlds.
Literature, languages and the arts explore identity, imagination, experience and expression.
These disciplines are not peripheral to the modern world.
They are essential to understanding it.
Technical knowledge tells us what we can do. The humanities and social sciences help us examine what we are doing, why we are doing it and what consequences follow.
VI. The irony: the more technologically sophisticated society becomes, the more it needs the humanities
We are entering a period of extraordinary technological change.
Artificial intelligence, biotechnology, robotics, data analytics and advanced engineering will increasingly influence the organisation of human society.
But technical capability does not automatically produce good judgement.
We have already examined the human tendency to substitute emotional response for evidence, defend existing beliefs, pursue short-term advantage and avoid responsibility for collective decisions.
Artificial intelligence may amplify these problems if the systems are built around defective assumptions.
A technically sophisticated society requires people capable of examining the social and ethical consequences of technological development.
We need philosophers examining responsibility.
Sociologists examining institutional power.
Historians examining the consequences of previous technological and political transformations.
Anthropologists examining cultural differences.
Psychologists examining human behaviour.
Political scientists examining governance.
Ethicists examining competing obligations.
And we need scientists, engineers and technologists willing to engage seriously with those disciplines.
The separation of technical and human knowledge is itself a problem.
We are building increasingly powerful tools while struggling to develop a shared understanding of how those tools should be used.
The humanities are not an obstacle to technological progress.
They are among the means by which technological progress can be directed towards human benefit.
There is a considerable irony in a society that invests heavily in developing increasingly sophisticated technologies while allowing the disciplines that examine their human consequences to become institutionally vulnerable.
We should be strengthening the relationship between technical and human knowledge, not encouraging their separation.
VII. The long-term consequences of short-term metrics
Markets are very good at measuring certain things.
They can measure revenue, cost, demand, productivity and financial return.
But they are less effective at measuring benefits that emerge slowly or are distributed across society.
Consider a historian whose research changes the way Australians understand an important period of their national history.
The benefit may emerge over decades.
Consider a sociologist who identifies patterns of institutional exclusion.
The research may not produce a commercial product, but it may help inform better public policy.
Consider a philosopher examining the ethical implications of artificial intelligence.
The immediate financial return may be negligible, yet the work may help establish principles that prevent serious harm.
Consider an anthropologist documenting the cultural knowledge of an Indigenous community.
The value cannot reasonably be reduced to the number of citations, the revenue generated or the number of commercial partnerships established.
These are examples of knowledge whose benefits may be social, cultural, intellectual or intergenerational.
The difficulty is that university funding and management systems often operate within shorter planning cycles.
Annual budgets, grant periods, performance reviews and institutional targets can favour outputs that are comparatively easy to demonstrate.
This creates a structural problem.
The market tends to reward what can be monetised. Society also depends upon things that cannot be adequately priced.
This is not an argument against commercial research, employment-focused education or financial accountability.
It is an argument against treating commercial value as the complete measure of intellectual value.
The value of knowledge cannot always be determined by the speed with which it produces a monetary return.
Some knowledge prevents harm. Some challenges institutional assumptions. Some preserves cultural memory. Some helps societies recognise mistakes before they become disasters.
The absence of an immediate financial return does not mean the absence of value.
VIII. What should a university actually produce?
The question is not whether universities should prepare people for employment.
They must.
Nor is the answer to abandon technical education, commercial research or professional training.
Those are essential components of higher education.
The question is whether they should become the dominant measures of educational success.
A university should prepare people to participate in society, not merely to enter the labour market.
It should develop technical competence while also cultivating critical judgement.
It should encourage commercial innovation while examining its ethical and social consequences.
It should produce graduates capable of earning a living and understanding the lives of people whose circumstances differ from their own.
It should preserve knowledge that may have no immediate commercial application but could prove invaluable to future generations.
It should provide a space in which accepted assumptions can be challenged.
And it should help society understand itself.
Perhaps the expression seekers of wisdom sounds too philosophical for an institutional policy document, but the underlying objective is entirely practical.
We need graduates who are:
- Intellectually independent.
- Capable of examining evidence.
- Able to recognise uncertainty.
- Prepared to challenge defective assumptions.
- Conscious of the social and ethical consequences of their work.
- Capable of understanding different cultural and human experiences.
- Willing to revise their conclusions when better evidence becomes available.
- Prepared to accept responsibility for the consequences of their decisions.
These qualities are not the exclusive property of the humanities.
They should be cultivated across the university.
A scientist needs ethical judgement. An engineer needs social understanding. An economist needs historical perspective. A philosopher needs intellectual discipline and evidence. A computer scientist needs an understanding of the people affected by the systems being developed.
The objective should not be to produce graduates who merely possess knowledge.
It should be to develop people capable of applying knowledge responsibly.
That is a more demanding conception of education.
IX. The university, democracy and the public interest
There is another reason this matters.
Universities are not simply suppliers of skilled labour. They are important institutions within democratic society.
Democracy requires citizens who can examine claims, evaluate evidence, recognise manipulation and question the exercise of authority.
It requires people who understand how institutions operate, how power is distributed and how public decisions affect different communities.
The study of history helps citizens recognise the consequences of previous political and institutional failures.
Sociology helps reveal patterns of inequality and exclusion.
Political science helps explain governance and public accountability.
Philosophy helps examine the ethical foundations of laws, rights and responsibilities.
The humanities and social sciences therefore contribute to democratic capacity.
A society that neglects these disciplines risks weakening some of the intellectual resources through which citizens can examine the institutions governing them.
This is particularly concerning in an age of artificial intelligence.
We are developing systems capable of generating information, influencing public discussion, classifying individuals and assisting in consequential administrative decisions.
Citizens will need the capacity to question how these systems work, what assumptions they contain and whose interests they serve.
Technical knowledge will be important, but it will not be sufficient.
We need people who can ask whether a system is fair, whether its objectives are legitimate, whether its classifications reflect reality and whether its consequences are acceptable.
Those questions require an understanding of human beings and the societies in which they live.
The university should be helping to develop precisely that capacity.
X. The unfinished responsibility of higher education
The Australian Universities Accord, commissioned in 2022 and reported in 2024, recognised substantial weaknesses in existing funding and governance arrangements.
It identified problems involving participation, funding stability, research, university financial sustainability and the relationship between education and national skills requirements.
Its examination of Job-ready Graduates was particularly revealing.
The Accord found that the policy’s price signals had largely failed to influence student choices as intended, while imposing significant financial disadvantages on students in particular disciplines.
It also emphasised the importance of basic research, longer grant periods and maintaining a strong foundation for university research.
These findings demonstrate that concerns about the existing system are not confined to external critics.
The government’s own review identified substantial structural problems.
But recommendations do not automatically change institutional culture.
The important question is whether reform changes the incentives governing university behaviour or simply introduces another layer of administrative measurement.
Will universities be encouraged to value long-term intellectual development alongside immediate employment outcomes?
Will humanities and social sciences be recognised as essential components of a technologically sophisticated society?
Will academic independence be protected while maintaining appropriate accountability?
Will research funding recognise social and intellectual benefits that cannot be reduced to commercial return?
Will universities be evaluated partly on their contribution to democratic understanding, ethical judgement and the development of independent thought?
These are not unreasonable expectations.
They concern the public purpose of institutions that receive public funding and occupy an influential position in Australian society.
XI. Conclusion: The market can price knowledge, but can it measure wisdom?
The transformation of Australian higher education over the past four decades demonstrates the increasing influence of market mechanisms, financial performance measurement and managerial governance.
The Dawkins reforms helped establish a more competitive, mass-participation system.
Subsequent changes strengthened institutional performance management and commercial expectations.
The Job-ready Graduates policy introduced explicit price signals intended to influence student choices and prioritise selected workforce areas.
International student revenue became an increasingly important component of university finances.
These developments have produced opportunities as well as difficulties.
The expansion of higher education has widened access. Industry partnerships have supported research and innovation. Employment-focused education has helped address important skills needs. Financial accountability is necessary.
But the cumulative effect raises a fundamental question about institutional purpose.
When the financial return of a discipline becomes the principal measure of its value, the university risks neglecting knowledge whose benefits are long-term, collective and difficult to monetise.
History, sociology, philosophy, anthropology and the creative arts do not exist outside the economy.
They contribute to the development of citizens, institutions, professional judgement and social understanding.
Their contribution is simply not always visible on an annual balance sheet.
And perhaps that is the central problem.
We have become increasingly sophisticated at measuring the economic output of education.
But we have not developed an equally persuasive system for recognising its contribution to human understanding.
A society needs engineers to build its infrastructure.
It needs scientists to extend its knowledge.
It needs doctors, nurses and teachers to sustain its people.
But it also needs historians to understand its past, sociologists to examine its institutions, philosophers to question its assumptions and artists to explore its humanity.
Without those disciplines, we may become increasingly capable of changing the world while becoming progressively less capable of understanding the consequences.
There is a fundamental distinction between teaching people how to operate a system and preparing them to examine whether that system is worthy of being operated.
The university should do both.
If intelligence helps us operate the system, critical thinking helps us examine it and wisdom helps us recognise when it needs changing, what happens when we neglect the disciplines that teach us to examine the human experience?
We risk producing a society that is technically proficient, economically productive and administratively efficient, but insufficiently equipped to understand itself.
That would be a very expensive form of progress.
And this brings us to the principle that should guide the future of higher education:
We should not produce generations of people who know how to operate increasingly sophisticated systems but have insufficient opportunity to question whether those systems serve humanity.
A university should not merely teach people how to earn a living.
It should help them understand what living means, how societies function and what responsibilities accompany the exercise of knowledge and power.
The market can tell us what knowledge is worth to a purchaser.
It cannot, by itself, tell us what knowledge is worth to humanity.
That responsibility belongs to a society capable of examining its own priorities.
And perhaps that is the unfinished task of the university: not simply to transmit knowledge, but to help develop the intellectual independence, critical judgement and ethical responsibility through which knowledge can become wisdom.
Andrew Klein
The Patrician’s Watch