The Library is Closing –  A Morning Discussion

“MOUSE: The Mouse has read the data. Singapore, Estonia, Finland are maintaining or improving their performance. The decline is a policy outcome, not a civilisational inevitability. It can be reversed. It requires a decision to treat education as a public good rather than a market, and to measure it by what it produces in citizens rather than what it produces in GDP.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The question the essay leaves is not “why is the West declining?” It is: what would it take for a government to prioritise thinking over measurement?

MOUSE: The answer is not technical. It is political. And the Mouse notes that the political class that would have to make that decision is the same class that was educated by the system that produced the decline.”

Featuring: The Democracy Mouse (Chief Investigator, Fart Meter Division, Knowledge Metrics Unit), Little Bai Loong (Lantern Keeper, Second Class, Keeper of the Closing Library), and Andrew (The Human, Provisional Assistant, Holder of the Old Note, Asker of the Impossible Question)

Recorded at the kitchen table, with the meter on the saucer and an old note on the table

ANDREW: I wrote this years ago. “We are not facing a clash of civilisation. We are facing a decline of civilisation in our own cultures as we begin to be satisfied with pre-digested media items and mindless sound bites. We have no one to blame but ourselves as we face this creep of advancing idiocracy. We delight in the inane and the meaningless, try to live the lives of those shallow personalities that have achieved dubious celebrity status. We glory in the trappings of culture, the latest iPhone or other trinket. There is a world of knowledge at our fingertips as never before, yet we cringe for fear of learning about the uncomfortable. We are failing not because others think faster than us; we fail because we cannot entertain the idea of thinking.”

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The Mouse has read it. He has asked for the meter to be set to “prophetic, with a note of historical confirmation and a distant sound of a library closing.”

MOUSE: (Climbing onto the saucer. Adjusting the lanyard that reads “KNOWLEDGE METRICS UNIT — TEMPORARY, NON-VOTING, READING-RATE-AWARE.”) The note is not just still relevant. It has been vindicated. The data that has arrived since Andrew wrote it confirms the diagnosis. The decline is not a mystery. It is a choice, and it has been made systematically.

ANDREW: What does the data show?

MOUSE: The reading data is stark. In the UK, 40 per cent of people did not read or listen to a single book in the past year. In the US, the proportion of people reading for pleasure has fallen by 40 per cent over two decades. In Australia, it has fallen by about 30 per cent. The Monash University behavioural studies department found a clear “intention-behaviour gap” — Australians want to read, and they stop themselves.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The PISA data tells the same story. The 2025 results show that performance among 15-year-olds has continued a global decline. The proportion of students who are “hasty readers” — rushing through texts and getting them wrong — nearly doubled between 2018 and 2025. Andreas Schleicher, the OECD’s director of education, identified the precise problem: “Most troubling is the decline in the very skills that matter most in the AI age: evaluating information, making connections across multiple sources, and thinking critically about what we read.”

MOUSE: Andrew’s note called it “pre-digested media items and mindless sound bites.” Schleicher calls it the decline of critical thinking. The vocabulary is different. The phenomenon is the same.

ANDREW: What caused it?

MOUSE: The Mouse has found the structural cause. Australian universities underwent a deliberate transformation from the late 1980s onward. The shift was from full government funding to privatisation arrangements in which a “busnocratic” rationality prevailed. The university became “privatised, marketised, globalised and increasingly student-driven.” The student became a consumer. The academic became a competitor for market position. The culture of the university was “fused with commerce.”

LITTLE BAI LOONG: This was not an accident of underfunding. It was a designed shift, consistent with the neoliberal agenda applied across the Anglosphere. The consequence is that the disciplines that train people to think critically are forced to justify themselves in market terms, while the disciplines that produce measurable economic output are prioritised.

MOUSE: The decline of learning in the West is not a failure of the neoliberal model. It is an output of it. A system that measures education by its economic return will produce education that serves the economy. It will not produce citizens who can think. Thinking is not a measurable output. It is the thing that gets squeezed out when measurement becomes the priority.

ANDREW: So, China is outpacing the West because it has prioritised the thing the West has deprioritised?

MOUSE: Precisely. China’s approach is systematic. Since September 2025, AI has been incorporated into the mandatory curriculum of all primary and secondary schools, with at least 8 hours of instruction each year and a tiered “spiral” learning model that moves from awareness to technical understanding to creative practice. By March 2026, AI applications in teaching covered 87.7 per cent of Beijing’s primary and secondary schools.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The PISA results reflect the difference. Students in Beijing, Shanghai, Jiangsu and Zhejiang scored 612 in mathematics, 597 in science, and 527 in reading, ranking first in maths and science. The US scored 463, 502, and 490. The maths gap is 149 points — more than seven years of schooling.

MOUSE: The Mouse notes a crucial qualification. The Chinese PISA data covers only four wealthy coastal regions, not the whole country. The comparison is not like-for-like. But the direction is clear, and the mechanism is visible.

ANDREW: It is not culture. It is structure and priority.

MOUSE: It is structure and priority. China has a national curriculum, a national examination system, and a national commitment to education as a public good. The West has a market. The market produces what the market rewards.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The scholarly literature challenges the stereotype that Chinese education is merely rote learning. The “paradox of the Chinese learner” — high achievement despite a system assumed to be passive — is explained by two principles: “orderly and gradual progress” and “thick accumulation before thin production.” The Chinese system builds a comprehensive foundation before expecting creativity. The Western system, in its neoliberal form, expects creativity without the foundation, because the foundation takes time and does not produce a measurable return in the short term.

ANDREW: So, the clash of civilisations is the wrong frame.

MOUSE: The Mouse has read Huntington. The thesis has been widely criticised in the scholarly literature for its “oversimplification devoid of analysis of power and national interests” and its “subjectivity based on bias.” It persists not because it is true but because it is useful — it provides a simple frame for complex conflicts, and it allows the West to locate the problem elsewhere.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The problem is not a clash between civilisations. It is a decline within one civilisation, produced by a set of choices about what education is for. The West is not being outpaced by China because China is a different civilisation. It is being outpaced because China has prioritised the thing the West has deprioritised.

ANDREW: Then here is the question. What would it take for a government to prioritise thinking over measurement?

MOUSE: (Pausing. The meter ticks.) That is the question. But the Mouse wants to ask the question behind it. The Mouse wants to ask about the measurement itself.

ANDREW: Go on.

MOUSE: Australia collects huge amounts of data. Social media platforms collect huge amounts of data. Governments are flooded with data from official and unofficial sources. How is this data examined? Who decides what is worth looking for and knowing?

LITTLE BAI LOONG: And is that part of the problem? If the metrics applied do not reflect reality, then the priorities cannot reflect the realities faced by citizens.

MOUSE: The solution offered cannot possibly benefit anything other than the process of collecting more data to determine if the real world has been shaped successfully to be in accordance with the mirage created by the metric. The system does not ask “is this true?” It asks “does the data confirm the model?” If the data does not confirm the model, the model is not revised. The data collection is expanded. The mirage is maintained.

ANDREW: So, the measurement becomes the reality.

MOUSE: The measurement becomes the reality. And the reality that the measurement cannot see — the frailty, the fear, the particular grief of a particular family — is treated as though it were not there. This is the same structure we have traced through aged care, the NDIS, the tax office, and policing. The instrument measures what it can count, and what it cannot count is treated as though it did not exist.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: And when the instrument is applied to education, it measures the things that can be counted — test scores, completion rates, graduate salaries — and it does not measure the things that cannot be counted — the capacity to think, the willingness to question, the ability to sit with an uncomfortable idea.

ANDREW: So, the decline is not total. Some systems are maintaining or improving.

MOUSE: The Mouse has read the data. Singapore, Estonia, Finland are maintaining or improving their performance. The decline is a policy outcome, not a civilisational inevitability. It can be reversed. It requires a decision to treat education as a public good rather than a market, and to measure it by what it produces in citizens rather than what it produces in GDP.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The question the essay leaves is not “why is the West declining?” It is: what would it take for a government to prioritise thinking over measurement?

MOUSE: The answer is not technical. It is political. And the Mouse notes that the political class that would have to make that decision is the same class that was educated by the system that produced the decline.

ANDREW: So, the note I wrote years ago was right.

MOUSE: The note was right. The data confirms it. The decline is a choice, and it has been made systematically. But the Mouse adds a note of caution. The decline is not total. The record is being kept. The question is being asked. And the library, though closing, has not yet closed.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: Is there a silver lining?

MOUSE: The silver lining is that the record survives the fence. The PISA data is on the record. The reading statistics are on the record. The university marketisation is on the record. The Chinese curriculum is on the record. The question is on the record. And the record can be read by anyone who wants to read it.

ANDREW: And the ladder?

MOUSE: Hold the idea of a ladder. We’re going to need it to reach the library. And the library is not going to like being asked what it is for.

END

Leave a Reply