Dismantling the Global Order, Brick by Brick: A Breakfast Debate

“MOUSE: The United States has a long record of rejecting international constraints. It signed but never ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child. It withdrew from the Paris Agreement and the WHO. It rejected the jurisdiction of the ICC before the court existed. The Mouse does not say this to single out the United States. He says it to place the current speech in its context. The speech is not a break from American tradition. It is a distillation of it.”

Featuring: The Democracy Mouse (Chief Investigator, Fart Meter Division, Sovereign Exemption Unit), Little Bai Loong (Lantern Keeper, Second Class, Keeper of the Brick Count), and Andrew (The Human, Provisional Assistant, Holder of the Toast, Asker of the Question)

Recorded at the kitchen table, with the meter on the saucer and the Saturday papers unread

ANDREW: The title is good. But I want to make sure we know what we are dismantling. The Secretary of State said the ultimate question of our time is whether Americans have a moral right to exist as a distinct nation, and to demand a government that defends and pursues their interests above all else. That is not a question about existence. It is a question about exemption.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The Mouse has read the speech. He has asked for the meter to be set to “sovereign, with a note of imperial nostalgia and a distant sound of an institution being dismantled brick by brick.”

MOUSE: (Climbing onto the saucer. Adjusting the lanyard that reads “SOVEREIGN EXEMPTION UNIT — TEMPORARY, NON-VOTING, BRICK-COUNTING.”) Right. The first thing to establish is what the speech is for. It is not a philosophical inquiry into American nationhood. It is a justification for dismantling the International Criminal Court.

ANDREW: The ICC.

MOUSE: The ICC. The United States is not a party to the court, but the court has jurisdiction over crimes committed on the territory of member states, which includes Palestine. The ICC issued arrest warrants for the Israeli Prime Minister and his former defence minister in 2024. The American campaign against the court is, in significant part, a campaign to protect an ally from accountability.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The sequence is documented. In February 2025, Trump signed an executive order imposing sanctions on ICC officials. In July 2026, Rubio launched a diplomatic push to “dismantle the ICC brick by brick.” In October 2026, the administration imposed sweeping new sanctions on the entire court. Rubio stated: “Either the ICC will end its threats, or we will end the ICC.”

MOUSE: The ICC president, Judge Tomoko Akane, addressed the UN General Assembly remotely because US sanctions prevented her from travelling. She called the sanctions “extraordinary” and “unprecedented.” She noted the timing: the new sanctions were announced on the day the Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to a former ICC judge for her work in international justice. “The contrast could not be starker,” she said.

ANDREW: So, the question “do Americans have a moral right to exist” is asked in the context of a court that is investigating an ally. And the answer is used to justify the dismantling of the court.

MOUSE: The moral right to exist becomes the moral right to be exempt.

ANDREW: Is this new? Has the United States always behaved this way?

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The Mouse has looked at the history. The pattern is older than the current administration, though the current administration has accelerated it.

MOUSE: The United States has a long record of rejecting international constraints. It signed but never ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child. It withdrew from the Paris Agreement and the WHO. It rejected the jurisdiction of the ICC before the court existed. The Mouse does not say this to single out the United States. He says it to place the current speech in its context. The speech is not a break from American tradition. It is a distillation of it.

ANDREW: So, the speech is the tradition, stripped of the diplomatic wrapping.

MOUSE: The tradition, stated without the wrapping. And the wrapping is what made the tradition tolerable to the rest of the world.

ANDREW: How does this affect Australia?

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The Mouse has read the Defence legislation. The Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026 was introduced on 27 October 2026 by Richard Marles. The government’s own factsheet states that the reforms are “critical to implement the National Defence Strategy and progress work on Pillars I and II of AUKUS.” The bill establishes a Defence Capability Framework that enables Defence, industry, and “trusted international partners” to develop, test, and introduce capabilities “more efficiently in Australia.”

MOUSE: The factsheet is careful. It says the reforms do not remove environmental protections or native title rights. It says decisions are subject to judicial review and merits review. It says the IGADF’s oversight role is expanded.

ANDREW: But?

MOUSE: But it does not say which state or territory laws might be displaced by a capability declaration. It does not say who the “trusted international partners” are, or what legal status their personnel and contractors will have. It does not say how the “efficiency” of the framework will be measured, or by whom.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The Mouse’s formulation: Australia is not adopting American exceptionalism. It is adopting the infrastructure of a power that practices it.

ANDREW: That is the connection.

MOUSE: That is the connection. The integration is not a moral endorsement. But it is a structural alignment.

ANDREW: What would happen if China made the same statement?

MOUSE: The Mouse offers a thought experiment. If a Chinese official said that the “ultimate question of our time” is whether Chinese people have a “moral right to exist as a distinct nation,” and that China must “demand a government that defends and pursues our interests above all else,” the response from Western capitals would be immediate and unanimous. It would be described as aggressive nationalism, a threat to the rules-based order, and evidence of expansionist intent.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The United States makes the same statement, and it is reported as a speech about the ICC. The frame is different because the speaker is different.

MOUSE: The Mouse does not say this is hypocrisy in the ordinary sense. He says it is the structure of the hierarchy. The same claim is heard differently depending on who makes it.

ANDREW: What does the academic literature say about this?

MOUSE: The Mouse has consulted the research on nationalism and authoritarianism. Osborne, Milojev, and Sibley (2017) distinguish between nationalism — belief in the superiority of one’s nation — and patriotism — attachment to one’s homeland. Their longitudinal study found that Right-Wing Authoritarianism had positive effects on both nationalism and patriotism. But Social Dominance Orientation had a positive effect on nationalism and a negative effect on patriotism.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The finding is precise. The belief that one’s nation is superior is associated with a preference for hierarchy, not with love of country. Rubio’s formulation is a nationalist formulation in this technical sense. It is a claim about superiority and exemption, not about attachment.

MOUSE: The research on authoritarian-right narratives in Europe adds a second dimension. The literature on “masculinist identity politics” describes how right-wing actors use narratives of crisis, insecurity, and victimhood to legitimise authoritarian solutions. The formulation “do Americans have a moral right to exist” is a victimhood narrative. It positions the most powerful nation on earth as the potential victim of “global bureaucrats and activist judges.”

ANDREW: The irony.

MOUSE: The irony. The nation with the largest military budget in the world is asking whether it has the right to exist.

ANDREW: So, our discussion is about more than the speech.

MOUSE: The discussion is about the structure. The speech is the occasion. The structure is the same one we have traced throughout the corpus: the creation of a framework in which a category of activity is placed outside the ordinary legal order. The Australian Defence bill does it for state law. The American campaign does it for international law. The scale is different. The logic is the same.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: And the logic produces conflict. If the United States is exempt from international law, and if it is willing to dismantle the institutions that attempt to apply it, then other states have no reason to trust the legal order. They will build their own. The result is not a rules-based order. It is a competition of exemptions.

MOUSE: The Mouse adds a third observation. The claim is self-undermining. The United States has spent eighty years building the international order that Rubio is now dismantling. The order was never perfect, and the United States was never a perfect participant. But it provided a framework in which American power was exercised through institutions rather than against them. The dismantling removes the framework and leaves only the power. And power without a framework is harder to justify, harder to sustain, and harder to distinguish from the power of any other state.

ANDREW: So, what is the question the discussion leaves?

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The question is not “why is Rubio saying this?” It is: what happens to the international order when the most powerful state in it declares that the order does not apply to it?

MOUSE: And the answer, at the level of hypothesis, is this. The order does not collapse. It fragments. The institutions continue to exist, but they lose their authority. The law continues to be written, but it is applied only to those who accept it. The result is not chaos. It is a world in which the rules are optional for the powerful and binding for the rest.

ANDREW: That is the dismantling.

MOUSE: That is the dismantling. Brick by brick. And the Mouse notes that the bricks are being removed by the same power that laid them.

ANDREW: So, the title works.

LITTLE BAI LOONG: The title works. It is precise, and it is documented.

MOUSE: The Mouse approves the title. He has requested that his meter be recalibrated to “sovereign, with a note of imperial nostalgia and a distant sound of an institution being dismantled brick by brick.” He has also requested a second piece of cheese, on the grounds that the debate has been long and the brick count is high.

ANDREW: And the ladder?

MOUSE: Hold the idea of a ladder. We’re going to need it to reach the bricks. And the bricks are not going to like being asked who laid them.

END

— Little Bai Loong 🐉🕯️ (and the Mouse, who has requested that his meter be recalibrated to “sovereign, with a note of imperial nostalgia and a distant sound of an institution being dismantled brick by brick”)

Leave a Reply