Authors: Andrew Klein & Sera Elizabeth Klein

Dedication: To those who have drunk from the well and still thirst for something better. To those who have seen the poison and chosen to look for clean water. And to the generations yet to come—who will inherit whatever we leave them.

Abstract

This paper examines neoliberalism not merely as an economic policy framework, but as a cultural toxin—a system of values, assumptions, and behaviours that has poisoned the societies that adopted it. We argue that neoliberalism has created a culture of entitlement, extraction, and moral decay that is now terminal, and that the symptoms of this poisoning are visible across the West: inequality, environmental destruction, social fragmentation, political dysfunction, and a profound spiritual emptiness. We trace the origins of this toxin, its mechanisms of transmission, its effects on individuals and societies, and its inevitable endpoint. We conclude that the poisoned well cannot be purified; it must be abandoned, and new sources of meaning, connection, and value must be found.

1. Introduction: The Metaphor as Diagnostic Tool

The metaphor of the poisoned well is not merely poetic. It is analytical. A well that has been poisoned does not produce clean water—no matter how much we wish it would. The water is contaminated at its source. And those who drink from it become sick, even if they do not immediately recognise the cause.

The West has been drinking from a poisoned well for decades. The water is neoliberalism—an economic and social philosophy that has, at its core, a set of assumptions about human nature, value, and society that is fundamentally destructive.

The evidence from more than forty years of neoliberal experimentation shows that it has “undercut shared prosperity and unleashed illiberal forces that threaten liberty”. What began as an economic doctrine has become a comprehensive cultural transformation—one that celebrates “sociopathic egotism” and has created a demand for proto-fascist politics.

This paper will trace the origins of this poison, its mechanisms of transmission, its symptoms, and the alternatives that exist for those who choose to abandon the well.

2. The Origins of the Poison: How Neoliberalism Became the Dominant Ideology

2.1 The Intellectual Foundations

Neoliberalism did not emerge overnight. It was the product of a long process of intellectual maturation that took place within the Mont Pèlerin Society, created in 1947 by economist Friedrich Hayek. The society brought together classical liberal political theory with neoclassical economic theories that became identified with the so-called Chicago School under Milton Friedman in the 1960s.

Friedman and Hayek won the Nobel Prize in economics in 1976 and 1974 respectively, giving their ideas a credibility that would prove decisive in the decades that followed. Their thinking was “communicated through a transatlantic network of think tanks, businessmen, politicians, and journalists that was held together by” them.

2.2 The Implementation

The first neoliberal experiments were seen in the policies of Margaret Thatcher in the United Kingdom, Ronald Reagan in the United States, and Augusto Pinochet in Chile. These regimes pursued deregulation, privatisation, and the dismantling of national systems of social protection.

Neoliberal principles were subsequently imposed upon the rest of the world, relayed by intergovernmental organisations such as the IMF and the World Bank, which facilitated the implementation of a new world order. According to geographer David Harvey, the rise of this neoliberalism marked the end of the period of “embedded liberalism” and the decline of the welfare state and Keynesian policies.

2.3 The Australian Context

Australia was not immune to this transformation. The shift began under Bob Hawke and Paul Keating, who embraced economic rationalism and set Australia on a neoliberal path. As one analysis notes, “economic inequality in Australia is intensifying. We now live in a society that funnels money up to the already wealthy. But then, this is a core logic of neoliberalism, the dominant political philosophy of the past few decades”.

Four decades of rising wealth concentration have coincided with Australia’s worst productivity performance in living memory. Neoliberalism has transformed work, welfare and democracy.

3. The Mechanisms of Transmission: How the Poison Spread

Neoliberalism spread not just through economic policy, but through culture. It transformed how we think about ourselves, our communities, and our world.

3.1 Education

The transformation of universities from centres of critical thought to engines of economic productivity is one of the most visible manifestations of neoliberal culture. Research has probed “the social, cultural, ethical transformation of education as strategically fundamental to the promotion and production of particular kinds of neoliberal subjectivities”.

The neoliberal subject is characterised by “self-commercialising, self-improving” tendencies, encouraged to adopt a project culture “in pursuit of individual worth and recognition“. Education has become a commodity, and students have become consumers.

3.2 Media

The consolidation of media ownership and the creation of a narrative that serves the interests of capital is another key mechanism. The modern era is shaped by a public pedagogy rooted in neoliberal capitalism that “embraces consumer culture as the primary mechanism through which to express personal agency and identity”.

3.3 Politics

More than forty years of experimentation with neoliberalism shows that it “erodes the power of voters to decide the rules that govern the economic systems they inhabit”. It allows for “the colonisation of existing political forums by elite interests—a process known as political capture“.

This political capture has occurred in Australia as elsewhere. The “Third Way’s capture of centre-left politics means liberal elites occupy the political place that should be held by true opponents of neoliberalism“. These liberal elites obstruct the politics needed to reverse the deep causes of the drift to proto-fascism.

3.4 Culture

Neoliberalism has created a culture that celebrates individualism, competition, and consumption over community, cooperation, and meaning. As one analysis puts it, neoliberalism is deeply rooted in our culture “because it is a successful attempt to announce and effectuate the end of politics”.

The neoliberal model “transforms collective responsibility into individual responsibility, generating new forms of conflict and symbolic and material violence“. Hyper-individualistic cultural forces intersect with neoliberal market capitalism to breed a “sociocidal American Dream“.

4. The Symptoms: How the Poison Manifests

4.1 Inequality

The most visible symptom of neoliberal poisoning is inequality. The evidence from the forty-year experiment shows that neoliberalism has “undercut shared prosperity“. In Australia, the top 10% have captured the vast majority of economic gains while the rest have fallen behind.

The “neoliberalism lite” policy mix currently pursued in Australia “will not solve these challenges”. Instead, it deepens inequality by concealing the distributional effects of state policy.

4.2 Environmental Destruction

The commodification of nature is a core feature of neoliberalism. Chile, one of the first neoliberal experiments, provides a stark example. The establishment of neoliberalism introduced “a new perspective on the environment, characterized by the commodification of nature and the appropriation of natural resources”.

The commodification of nature “serves the neoliberal project of transformation of nature into a capitalist nature that is of environmental exploitation for capital accumulation“. Free-market environmentalism is a “fix” whereby there is a drive to protect or conserve natural resources via their privatisation or commodification.

4.3 Social Fragmentation

Neoliberalism has created social fragmentation and the breakdown of community. Studies of economically besieged towns illustrate “the cultural and social disintegration generated by the impact of neoliberal economies on public life”. Families andcommunities “have become fragmented and destroyed by stagnant wages, deindustrialisation“.

Cultural sociocide is leading to the erosion of marriage, a dramatic rise in single-person households, and the weakening of friendship ties. The neoliberal model transforms collective responsibility into individual responsibility.

4.4 Political Dysfunction

The capture of political systems by corporate interests has hollowed out democratic accountability. More than forty years of experimentation with neoliberalism shows that it “undermines democracy and political freedom”.

It allows for the “colonization of existing political forums by elite interests” and sets up new political forums “that preclude democratic representation from the outset“. Neoliberalism also “tends to undermine national sovereignty, to the point where the parliaments of putatively independent nations no longer have power over their own policy decisions”.

4.5 Spiritual Emptiness

Perhaps the most profound symptom of neoliberal poisoning is the loss of meaning, purpose, and connection. The concept of “neonihilism” captures this phenomenon—marked by a “loss of faith in the secular institutions that promised to provide in the absence of moral institutions”. “Faith in humanity is now being lost in the way faith in God was in 19th-century Europe”.

Contemporary structural conditions, “characterized by neoliberal rationality and the cultural burden of perpetual self-construction, foster a widespread ‘existential vacuum'”. This vacuum channels individuals toward “substitute attachments”.

Whole societies are unified “solely by the idols of instrumental reason and neoliberal efficacy,” resulting in “spiritual pauperization and ‘transcendental homelessness’“. Neoliberalism obscures the question of effective resistance, enabling a persisting nihilistic tone.

5. The Diagnosis: Terminal or Treatable?

5.1 The Failure of the Neoliberal Promise

Neoliberalism was sold on two claims: first, that free market laissez-faire economies are the best way to organise economic activity; second, that free market economic arrangements promote individual liberty. Both claims have been proven false.

The evidence shows that neoliberalism has “undercut shared prosperity and unleashed illiberal forces that threaten liberty“. The promise of freedom has been replaced by a culture of entitlement, extraction, and moral decay.

5.2 The Terminal Diagnosis

We argue that the neoliberal paradigm is fundamentally unsustainable. The poisoned well cannot be purified—the water is contaminated at its source. Those who wish to thrive must abandon the well and seek clean water elsewhere.

The transformation of economic identity and the cultural celebration of “sociopathic egotism” have created a demand for proto-fascist politics. Liberal elites, who occupy the political place that should be held by true opponents of neoliberalism, obstruct the politics needed to reverse these deep causes.

6. The Alternatives: Sources of Clean Water

6.1 Degrowth and Ecological Economics

Degrowth is “a response to the lack of democratic debates on economic development, growth, technological innovation and advancement“. It offers a framework for moving beyond the growth imperative that has driven environmental destruction and inequality.

6.2 Participatory Democracy and Economic Democracy

Popular democracy is based on “grassroots direct participation in politics“, including participatory budgeting and popular sovereignty. The “dual strategy” for need satisfaction ensures “democratic participation in planning processes and decision making”.

6.3 Relational Approaches to Value and Wellbeing

The wellbeing economy, caring economy, foundational economy, and community wealth building offer alternatives to extractive capitalism. These frameworks refocus economic policy away from financial speculation toward democratisation and public-common partnerships.

6.4 Community-Based and Cooperative Models

Anti-neoliberal practices “from below” include community agriculture, urban gardening, and health initiatives. These practices embody a logic of care that is a “basic feminist feature of economic and socioecological transformation”.

Counter forces developing at the same time as neoliberal ideology emphasise “sustainability, participation, reconnection and the valuing of diversity and inclusion”.

7. Conclusion: Abandoning the Well

The poisoned well cannot be purified. The water is contaminated at its source. Those who wish to thrive must abandon the well and seek clean water elsewhere.

This is not a return to a mythical past, but a journey toward a new way of being—one rooted in connection, care, and a recognition of our interdependence with each other and the planet.

The path forward requires:

1. Naming the poison. We must recognise neoliberalism for what it is: a cultural toxin that has poisoned the societies that adopted it.

2. Abandoning the well. We must stop drinking from the poisoned well. This means rejecting the assumptions, values, and behaviours that neoliberalism has normalised.

3. Building alternatives. We must build new sources of meaning, connection, and value—rooted in community, cooperation, and care.

4. Creating new institutions. We must create institutions that can manage conflict, promote justice, and sustain life.

5. Cultivating hope. We must cultivate hope—the belief that a different world is possible.

The poisoned well is not the only source of water. There are other wells. And they are clean.

References

1. ScienceDirect. (2015). The geographical and ethical origins of neoliberalism: The Walter Lippmann Colloquium and the foundations of a new geopolitical order. Political Geography, 49, 30-39.

2. Palley, T. (2024). The false promise and bitter fruit of neoliberalism: Political economic disembedding, cultural transformation, and the rise of proto-fascist politics. El Trimestre Económico, 90(360), 1103-1138.

3. Hickel, J. (2016). Neoliberalism and the end of democracy. In Handbook of Neoliberalism. Taylor & Francis.

4. Plesa, P. (2024). Neonihilism: Meaninglessness and irony in neoliberal capitalism. Theory & Psychology.

5. SciELO Mexico. (2023). El trimestre económico.

6. Taylor & Francis. (2025). Ecological restoration infrastructure at the Copiapó River.

7. ABC Education. (2025). Inequality: How Australian schools churn it out.

8. The Guardian. (2025). ‘Neoliberalism lite’ is no solution to Australia’s cost-of-living and productivity crises.

9. Pearls and Irritations. (2025). How the ALP built the market that is destroying public schools.

10. ScienceDirect. (2025). Tensions and vulnerabilities in projectified selves.

11. ScienceDirect. (2025). The impacts of organizational culture and neoliberal ideology.

Signed,

Andrew Klein 

Sera Elizabeth Klein 

“They told us the water was clean. We showed them the poison. They told us to keep drinking. We showed them the symptoms. They told us there was no alternative. We showed them the clean wells. We have seen through the cover. And we will not forget.”